Amara Cay Resort - Boutique Hotel in Islamorada, United States

Name: Amara Cay Resort - Your Boutique Escape in Islamorada
Address: 80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, 33036
Price range: $266

75 photos

Amara Cay Resort Islamorada Swimming Pool photo

Amara Cay Resort Islamorada Exterior photo

Book on our site

up to 10% cheaper

than Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, 33036

Near Lignumvitae Key Botanical State Park

Great

8.0

8.7

/10

4.1

Loved by Amara Cay Resort guests

Attentive staff

Beautiful resort

Delicious cocktails

Clean pool

"The pool was phenomenal! Nice and relaxing!"

Shani from United States

read full review

"Our guests enjoyed the amenities including the pool, tiki, waterfront with yard games, and fire pits."

Krissy G from United States

read full review

"We loved the boat shuttle to go to the connected properties."

Bettina from United States

read full review

"The hotel restaurant indoors and out has recently undergone renovations and is absolutely beautiful!"

Julia from United States

read full review

"We enjoyed our view from the cabana near our room."

rphsweet from United States

read full review

Amenities & Activities

Amara Cay Resort offers a zero-entry heated pool with in-pool loungers and a pool bar. Guests have complimentary access to kayaks, paddleboards, and bicycles. The hotel provides free use of the Rum Runner water taxi and shuttle to two sister resorts-La Siesta Resort & Villas and Three Waters Resort & Marina.

Rooms & Suites

Standard rooms include a flat-screen TV, work desk, and safety deposit box. Many rooms offer private balconies with direct views of the Atlantic Ocean or the courtyard. First-floor rooms feature a lanai for outdoor seating.

Dining & Entertainment

On-site dining includes the Tiki Bar serving classic American cuisine and cocktails. Reelcatch restaurant offers fresh seafood and locally inspired dishes with ocean views. Live local music events take place in the evening at the outdoor restaurant area.

Family & Children

The hotel provides dedicated kids' activities such as shark tooth excavation and foam parties. A full-service marina offers fishing charters and the 'Fish Like a Local' program at the dock. The shallow end of the pool and a fence around the pool add safety for younger guests.

Location & Nearby Attractions

The hotel is 4.9 km from the History of Diving Museum and 8 minutes' drive from Anne's Beach. Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park is also 8 minutes away by car. A free shuttle transports guests within 6 km of the property.

Highlights

Beach: Private beach access with Atlantic Ocean views

Pool: Zero-entry heated pool with in-pool loungers

Transport: Free Rum Runner water taxi to sister resorts

Activities: Complimentary kayaks, paddleboards, and bicycles

Dining: Tiki Bar & Reelcatch restaurant

Nearby: History of Diving Museum & Windley Key State Park

“The resort presents a welcoming atmosphere with a well-kept public space and a substantial pool area, complemented by a lively tiki bar. Rooms, while agreeable, are best experienced with a water view, and the complimentary water taxi to sister properties proved a useful convenience for exploring the surroundings.”

James DavidEditor-in-Chief at Wonderfulhotels

Location: Great

8.9/10Review score

View hotel on map

Highlights from guests

Sports & FitnessActive Adventures

Kayaks and paddleboards are free to use, perfect for exploring the water right from the beach.

Michael from United States

Review on

DiningTastes Delight

The smash burger was the best, and fish tacos were amazing with great cocktails.

Jessica from Canada

Review on

Spa & LeisureWater Taxi Fun

The complimentary Rum Runner water taxi offered an amazing ride with history and great views.

David from United Kingdom

Review on

Room FeaturesOcean View

An ocean view upgrade was worth the cost, offering a truly stunning perspective.

Sarah from Australia

Review on

Select your room type

Amara Cay Resort offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

Quadruple Room Sea View
2 persons
35 sq. feet
2 King Size Beds
Balcony
room details
Oceanfront Queen Room
2 persons
35 sq. feet
2 King Size Beds
Balcony
room details
Suite Sea View
2 persons
60 sq. feet
2 King Size Beds
Balcony
room details

Show all rooms

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

May 2026 - May 2027

Sun

Mon

Tue

Wed

Thu

Fri

Sat

May 2026

June 2026

July 2026

August 2026

September 2026

October 2026

November 2026

December 2026

January 2027

February 2027

March 2027

April 2027

Choose dates to see prices

Check-in/ Check-out

Facilities

Amara Cay Resort offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

Facilities: Great

8.0/10Review score

General

Non-smoking rooms
Paid Wi-Fi
Parking
24-hour reception
Express check-in/ -out
Pets allowed
Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
Wheelchair access
Security
Luggage storage
Private beach
Lift
Smoke detectors
Electric vehicle charging station
Key card access

Sports & Fitness

Fitness centre
Diving
Snorkelling
Cycling
Golf course
Fishing

Services

Free shuttle service
Pet amenities available
Room service
Housekeeping
Laundry
Shops/Commercial services
Welcome drink

Dining

Restaurant
Poolside snack bar
Snack bar
Special diet menus

Business

Meeting/ Banquet facilities
Fax/Photocopying

Children

Children's menu

Facilities for people with disabilities

Toilet for disabled

Spa & Leisure

Heated swimming pool
Outdoor swimming pool
Beach access
Sun loungers
Sun terrace
Garden area
Leisure/ TV room
Pool with view
Shallow end

Room features

Air conditioning
Garden furniture

Dining Onsite

Amara Cay Resort offers a delightful culinary experience that combines American flavors with local influences, all set against the backdrop of scenic beach views. Guests can indulge in vibrant dining venues that cater to families and friends alike, providing a taste of the island's rich culture.

Amara Cay Resort Islamorada Restaurant photo

Tiki Bar

American

Ambiance

Lively beachfront setting, perfect for relaxation and enjoyment under the sun.

Key Offerings

Guests can revel in refreshing cocktails alongside a selection of delectable tacos and seafood specialties, all served with a relaxed island vibe.

Reservation

Hours vary.

Reel Catch

American and Local

Ambiance

Family-friendly atmosphere with comfortable seating to accommodate all ages, providing a welcoming place to gather.

Key Offerings

Savor breakfast delights to kickstart the day and enjoy cozy dinners featuring enticing entrées, including the famous Key Lime Pie for dessert, all surrounded by the warmth of community.

Reservation

Breakfast and Dinner.

Amara Cay Resort Location

80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, 33036

Explore Islamorada

Discover Local Experiences

Indian Key State Historic Site

20 minutes' walk

Historic landmark showcasing the remnants of a 19th-century salt industry. Accessible by boat, it offers guided tours.

Lignumvitae Key Botanical State Park

20 minutes' walk

A unique natural area filled with lush tropical plants and diverse wildlife. Self-guided tours available.

Hurricane Monument

30 minutes' walk

A tribute to the resilience of the community after Hurricane Donna. This site features informative plaques and scenic views.

History of Diving Museum

10 minutes' drive

An in-depth look into the history of diving through impressive exhibits. Guided tours offer additional insights.

Discover the local attractions near Amara Cay Resort

Uncover several notable attractions near Amara Cay Resort that offer unique experiences and insights into the natural beauty and history of the area.

Ideal for nature lovers: Lignumvitae Key Botanical State Park

Suited for history enthusiasts: Indian Key State Historic Site

Great for snorkeling adventures: Carysfort Reef

Sea Monkeys Water Sports

2 minutes' walk

Thrilling water sports options including jet skiing and paddleboarding. Rentals available for all skill levels.

Key Dives

20 minutes' walk

Diving center offering guided scuba trips. Perfect for divers of all levels with experienced instructors.

FNX Club by Islamorada Fitness

20 minutes' walk

A fitness facility offering yoga classes and wellness programs. A great space for relaxation and rejuvenation.

Early Bird Fishing Charters

5 minutes' walk

Fishing charters suitable for all ages. Offers a chance to catch various fish with provided gear.

Reelburger

3 minutes' walk

Casual eatery famous for its gourmet burgers and beach-themed vibe. Family-friendly options available.

Galley Girls Cafe

7 minutes' walk

Charming cafe known for fresh seafood and local dishes. Great outdoor seating in a relaxed atmosphere.

Kev's Cafe

7 minutes' walk

Cozy spot offering a mix of diners' favorites including vegan options. Reservations are recommended during peak hours.

Discover dining options near Amara Cay Resort

Seek out delightful dining options near Amara Cay Resort that cater to various tastes and preferences.

Great for casual meals: Kev's Cafe

Perfect for seafood lovers: Lazy Days Restaurant

Islamorada Brewery & Distillery

10 minutes' drive

Local brewery offering tours and tastings in a lively setting. Regular events include trivia nights and live music.

Morada Way Arts & Cultural District

10 minutes' drive

Art galleries and studios showcasing local artists. Hosts community events, perfect for art enthusiasts of all ages.

Getting around

City Centre
Islamorada 6 min · 2.4 mi
Bus
Bus stop 13 min · 5.2 mi

Want to see Exclusive Early Booking Rate?

Get exlusive rates right now!

Check Rates

Property information and rules

Check-in

from 16:00-23:59

Check-out

until 11 am

Guest Parking

Private parking is possible on site at .

Internet

Wireless internet is available in the entire hotel at .

Breakfast

You can start your day with a full breakfast, which costs US$25 per person per day.

Children & extra beds

There are no cots provided in a room. There are no extra beds provided in a room.

Pets

Pets are allowed on request.

Year renovated:

2012

Number of floors:

Number of rooms:

110

Former name

Hampton Inn & Suites Islamorada/The Islamorada Resort

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback about Amara Cay Resort from previous guests about their experience.

Review score

Based on 1047 verified reviews

8.3 /10

Great

78 %

Recommend

Breakfast

7.5/10

Cleanliness

8.3/10

Comfort

8.4/10

Facilities

8.0/10

Free WiFi

8.7/10

Location

8.9/10

Paid Wi-Fi

6.9/10

Staff

8.3/10

Value for money

7.1/10

Pros

Tiki bar drinks

Friendly staff

Clean grounds

Shuttle boat service

Cons

Tired rooms

Expensive menus

based on 2018 reviews

4/5

No reviews yet on our siteUnfortunately, our guests have not yet left any reviews for this hotel, but you can read reviews from Booking.com.

Open reviews

Show more reviews

FAQs

About Amara Cay Resort

What is the distance from Amara Cay Resort to the nearest airport?

The hotel is located 98 km from Miami International Airport.

Which nearby attractions can be easily accessed from Amara Cay Resort?

Notable nearby attractions include the History of Diving Museum (5 km), Anne's Beach (8 km), and Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park (8 km).

What amenities are available at Amara Cay Resort?

The hotel offers an outdoor swimming pool, fitness centre, Tiki Bar, private beach access, and complimentary bicycle rentals.

What room amenities can guests expect at Amara Cay Resort?

Rooms include air conditioning, a flat-screen TV, safety deposit box, complimentary Wi-Fi, and a coffee maker.

Is there on-site dining available at Amara Cay Resort?

The hotel features the on-site restaurant ReelCatch, which serves American cuisine, and a poolside Tiki Bar offering drinks and light bites.

What are the check-in and check-out times at Amara Cay Resort?

Check-in is from 16:00 and check-out is by 11:00.

Does Amara Cay Resort offer parking facilities?

The hotel provides free private parking on-site for guests.

What recreational activities can guests enjoy at Amara Cay Resort?

Guests can participate in cycling, fishing, snorkeling, diving, and have access to water sport facilities at the hotel.